FOS decisions / Debt Management
Debt Management
Financial Ombudsman Service final decisions, reproduced verbatim from the FOS published decisions register.
Decisions
21
Upheld
1
Not upheld
20
Avg redress
£70
Upheld complaints (1)
Not-upheld complaints (20)
Decision DRN-6241935
A firm must show forbearance and support to consumers experiencing financial difficulties, but offering payment plans, payment holidays, and a hold period prior to debt sale constitutes reasonable conduct.
Not upheldMay 2026Clydesdale Bank
DRN-5986029A lender must carry out a reasonable and proportionate affordability assessment that is borrower-focused, considering whether repayments would cause financial difficulty for the consumer.
Not upheldMar 2026Jaja Finance Ltd
DRN-6244167Lenders must conduct reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before extending credit, but checks need not identify every possible risk factor if the credit limit is modest relative to declared income and no active adverse indicato
Not upheldBarclays Bank UK PLC
DRN-6266389Lenders must complete reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before lending, assessed based on information available at the point of application rather than with hindsight.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6261230
Lenders must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before lending, based on borrower-specific circumstances and the amount of credit being provided.
Not upheldPDL Finance Limited
DRN-6142869Lenders must carry out a reasonable and proportionate affordability assessment that is borrower-focused, considering whether repayment would be sustainable without causing adverse consequences.
Not upheldBlack Horse Limited
DRN-6277759A creditor must carry out proportionate affordability checks before entering into a credit agreement; if checks would have revealed unaffordability, the lending relationship may be unfair under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6294757
A lender acts fairly in providing credit if it conducts reasonable and proportionate affordability checks that verify income, assess living expenses with appropriate buffers, and confirm sustainable repayment capacity.
Not upheldZopa Bank Limited
DRN-6210167Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks appropriate to the level of credit being offered, with extended checks not necessarily required merely because a borrower has previous defaults if sufficient time has passed and inco
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc
DRN-6293168Lenders must carry out proportionate affordability checks at application, but without evidence of what reasonable checks would have revealed, the burden rests on the consumer to demonstrate unfairness.
Not upheldZopa Bank Limited
DRN-6268854A lender must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before providing credit, which may include reliance on credit reference agency data and statistical information rather than requiring full evidence of expenditure in
Not upheldDecision DRN-6292215
A creditor-debtor relationship is unfair under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 only where the relationship is demonstrably unfair to the debtor, assessed by reference to the creditor's conduct, information provided, commission
Not upheldVanquis Bank Limited
DRN-6272404A lender's initial lending decision is fair if based on reasonable and proportionate checks, and subsequent support obligations during persistent debt are met through appropriate notifications and suggested remedies.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6233093
A credit union must carry out reasonable affordability and creditworthiness checks before lending, but automated checks using income verification, credit reports, and ONS spending estimates are sufficient if they indicate sustainable repaym
Not upheldBank of Scotland plc
DRN-6293226A lender must conduct proportionate affordability checks appropriate to the credit amount and circumstances before providing credit.
Not upheldNational Westminster Bank Public Limited
DRN-6053808A bank may refuse to issue a new card where it has reasonable grounds to believe the consumer may have difficulty repaying amounts owed, even if an advisor previously suggested otherwise.
Not upheldLendable Ltd
DRN-6262538A lender must carry out reasonable and proportionate affordability checks before providing credit, assessing both the likelihood of sustainable repayment and the impact on the borrower's circumstances.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6095886
A lender may register a default in accordance with ICO guidance when a consumer is at least three months behind with payments, provided it has offered appropriate forbearance and clear notice.
Not upheldDecision DRN-6037890
A default may be fairly reported when a consumer is 3+ months in arrears, or when an agreed arrangement is broken by non-payment.
Not upheldMARKS AND SPENCER FINANCIAL SERVICES PLC
DRN-5970153Lenders must conduct proportionate affordability checks taking into account the loan amount, repayments, cost of credit, purpose, and consumer's circumstances, not a prescriptive set of checks.
Not upheld